Tag Archives: review

2016 Graco Extend2Fit Preview Review: 50 lbs Rear-Facing!

extend2fit - 8Update: Here is my review of the Graco Extend2Fit with 3 across guides.

Every now and then a car seat manufacturer comes along that raises the bar. A couple of years ago, Clek did it by becoming the first manufacturer in the US to offer 50-lb rear-facing seats with the Foonf. The ability to rear-face children in car seats until they reached 50 pound hadĀ been available in Sweden for years, but until a few years ago, it had not been an option available to parents in the United States.

Two years ago in 2014, Diono challenged Clek by offering not one, butĀ twoĀ 50-lb-capable rear-facing convertibles: the Rainier and the Pacifica, and offering each at a lower price than the Foonf. Clek, of course, responded soon after with the Fllo, which was cheaper and lighter than the Foonf and narrower than the Rainier and Pacifica.

Things stayed the same until 2015, when Safety 1st entered the 50-lb game this year with the Advance EX 65 Air+, which became the first 50-lb seat under around $300. It was bulkily-sized and bulkily-named, but it was more affordable. Finally, Graco has entered the 50-lb game with the soon-to-be released Graco Extend2Fit convertible, which promises 50-lbs of rear-facing goodness for under $200 MSRP. Is it too good to be true? Let’s take a look!

How long will children be able to rear- and forward-face inĀ theĀ Graco Extend2Fit?

Children will be able to rear-face from 4-50 lbs and forward face from 22-65 pounds. There is a 49″ height limit when forward-facing, the standard 1″ from the top of the seat rule applies when both rear- and forward-facing, and an infant insert must be used when your child is at the lower end of the weight range while rear-facing. There is a 10-position adjustable harness that tops out at 18 inches, and you can choose from 6 recline positions; 3 of which are designed for rear-facing and 3 of which are exclusive to forward-facing.

How much will theĀ Graco Extend2Fit weigh, and what are its dimensions?

The Extend2Fit is expected to weigh around 25 pounds and is about 20″ wide from one cupholder to the next, which means you’ll still want to consider seats like the Fllo and Foonf if you’re interested in narrow seats that allow you to rear-face to 50 pounds while still working in 3 across situations. Graco states that the seat is designed to be sufficiently compact such that an average-height man will be able to use a front passenger or driver seat immediately in front of the Extend2Fit without needing to pull the vehicle seat forward excessively. I’m not sure what that translates into in daily use, but I’ll be happy to test the seat and add it to my rear-facing convertible space guide once I have it in my hands.

How long will parents be able to useĀ theĀ Graco Extend2Fit?

Per Graco, the Extend2Fit has a 10-year shelf life, meaning you will potentially be able to get 10 years of use out of it. Practically speaking, you’re not going to get that much time with one child, as a child who used it from birth would almost certainly outgrow the forward-facing 65-pound limit long before reaching 10 years of age. However, you’ll definitely be able to use it for at least 6 years with most children, and even longer with shorter or lighter children. And quite frankly, the best combination / booster seats on the market, the Frontier G1.1 and Pinnacle G1.1, are still going to be the best choices for getting your kids to the point where they don’t need car seats anymore.

How much will theĀ Graco Extend2Fit cost, when’s the release date, and where can I buy it?

TheĀ Graco Extend2Fit is expected to cost $199, placing it right under the $200 barrier that’s often the most many parents can afford when it comes to car seats. You’ll be able to buy it at Amazon, and I’ll have a review ready as soon as I get my hands on one. It should be available for pre-order this December and formally ship in January 2016.

This is great news for fans of extended rear-facing and affordable car seats, and will hopefully lead to more parents taking advantage of the myriad of reasons to continue rear-facing past 1, 2, and into the preschool years.

ā€”

If you find the information on car safety, recommended car seats, and car seat reviews on this car seat blog helpful, you can shop through this Amazon link for any purchases, car seat-related or not. Canadians can shop through this link for Canadian purchases.

Lil Fan High-Back / Low-Back Booster Review: Sporty and Safe

If you’re a sports fan, you might have a lot of sports gearĀ around your home, and even within your vehicle. Perhaps you’re even raising a little MLB, NBA, NCAA, or NFL fan in the back seat. Whatever team you support, if you’re in the market for a booster seat, you might want to consider the Lil Fan High-Back / Low-Back booster seat series. They’re designed to keep your little ones safe while allowing them to show off their fan pride. Around where I live, most folks are for the Cubs, White Sox, Cardinals, Bears or Packers. There are still a few Bulls fans, but not like there used to be in the ’90s. At any rate, enough sports talk; let’s take a look at the Lil Fan Booster. I picked mine up, as usual, from Amazon, and decided to see if it held up on the safety end as well as it did from the sporty end.

2015Ā Lil Fan High-Back / Low-Back Booster – What’s the big deal?

lil fan booster 01The Lil Fan high-back / low-back booster, beneath its sports insignia, is a dual mode booster seat. In other words, it’s designed to be used with children who have outgrown forward-facing harnesses but who still aren’t ready to use the adult seat belt. To determine when kids are ready for the adult seat belt, I recommend the 5 step test.

The Lil Fan can be used in both a high-back booster and as a low-back booster. I prefer high-back boosters to low-back boosters, as they free you from depending on the vehicle’s seat to comfortably fit a child’s upper body (i.e., the torso) and from depending on the vehicle’s seat to include a well-fitting head rest. However, the low-back end allows you to continue using the booster if your child outgrows the high-back part before reaching the point where s/he no longer needs a booster.

Buy the Lil Fan booster on Sale at Amazon here.

Lil Fan High-Back / Low-Back Booster Limits for Weight and Height and Measurements

lil fan booster 05High-back booster:Ā 30 to 110 lbs. Your child must be between 38″ and 57″ tall, and according to the box, at least 4 years old. Personally, I recommend using rear-facing or forward-facing harnessed seats until your child isĀ at least 5 years old, as very few children will be physiologically or psychologically ready to use a boostered seat at that age.

Personally, I’m far more comfortable with 6, 7, or even 8 years of age if your harnessed seat will allow it. Oddly enough, the 4 year old minimum age range isn’t listed anywhere on the manual or booster itself.

Low-back booster:Ā 40 to 110 pounds. Your child must be between 40″ and 57″ tall and at least 4 years old, and the vehicle’s head restraint must provide an adequate head support.

lil fan booster 04Lifespan and other measurements:Ā The Lil Fan has a 6 year lifespan before
you will need to replace it due to expiration. You also need to replace it if it is involved in a crash. Seven height positions are included in the head support. The lowest of the 7 height positions is 14.5″ while the tallest is 20.5.” ThisĀ isn’t as high as that found in the best boosters and combination seats on the market, such as the Frontier G1.1 / 90 and Pinnacle G1.1 / 90, but it’s off to a very good start, and it’s better than a number of other boosters on the market.

The seat is 13″ deep and ranges from 10″ in width at the rear part of the seat to a max of 13″ by the cup holders. The seat itself measures 17″ in width at the armrests, which makes it a good choice for 3 across installations due to its narrowness. You can check out the full 3 across car seat guide for more tips of combinations likely to work in your car, SUV, pickup truck, or minivan.

Using theĀ Lil Fan High-Back / Low-Back Booster

Vehicle fit

The Lil Fan was easy to set up out of the box, and it’ll only take you a few minutes to have it in ready to use condition in your given vehicle. At 17 inches across, it’s a good booster for 3 across setups. There are narrower boosters out there, like the Clek Oobr, but of course, they won’t come with your favorite fan branding. Using the cup holder will increase the width, of course.

Child fit

lil fan booster 02The Lil Fan fits a good range of kids, although it’s definitely not the tallest-fitting booster on the market. That award goes to the Frontier G1.1 / 90 and the Pinnacle G1.1 / 90. That said, you can still get a child most of the way (and in some cases all the way) with the Lil Fan in its high-back mode without resorting to the low-back mode. Remember to look for the signs to let you know when your child is and isn’t ready to go without a booster. If your child doesn’t pass the 5-step test before outgrowing the Lil Fan in the high-back mode, s/he almost certainly will before outgrowing the low-back mode.

When using a dual mode booster seat like the Lil Fan, there are a few elements to keep in mind. First of all, the shoulder belt guide must always be either at or just above your child’s shoulders; you adjust this by adjusting the booster’s head rest height. If you reach a point in high-back mode where your child’s shoulders are above the highest height setting for the shoulder belt guide, you’ll need to remove the high back and use the low-back mode, or the bottom.

Comfort and Maintenance

The Lil Fan series are comfortable seats with a light amount of padding throughout the body. Maintenance is relatively simple; you simply remove the cover and machine wash it in cold water. You’ll want to use a mild detergent and the delicate or gentle cycle, and it’s best to line-dry the fabric to reduce wear. To remove the cover, you unsnap it from the high-back and pull off the elastic on the low-back.

Buy the Lil Fan booster on Sale at Amazon here.

Why Buy theĀ Lil Fan High-Back / Low-Back Booster?

As wonderfulĀ as it is to have the wide range of teamsĀ available through the Lil Fan series, for me, the most important element of this car seat, and of any car seat, isn’t aesthetic, but functional. The question I’m always asking myself is how good of a job the seat does when it comes to keeping kids safe. And when it comes to keeping kids safe in a booster seat, I prefer to see them spend several years in two kinds of seatsĀ before ever sitting in a booster. That means rear-facing for as long as possible before forward-facing (ideally until 4 or even 5!), and once forward-facing, doing so for a number of years (ideally until 8!) before beginning to booster. Finally, once kids are boostering, I like to see them using boosters for as long as it takes until they can sit in vehicle seats with adult seat belts safely; that usually takes most kids until they’re between 10 and 12.

The Lil Fan will do a good job in allowing most kids to use it until they pass the 5-step test. For most kids, this will require using it in both high-back and low-back modes, because a number of children may outgrow it in the high-back mode. If you’re looking for booster seats that will allow kids to use them in the high-back mode from start to finish,Ā you’re looking for a seat like the theĀ Frontier G1.1 / 90Ā andĀ Pinnacle G1.1 / 90. Those are the two best booster seats on the market right now.

That said, the Lil Fan set is a good one, and I have no hesitation when it comes to recommending it as a boostering option for parents, especially those who follow televised sports. It’s a safe, quality, and relatively affordable booster seat that’s far more appropriate for young children than sitting directly in a vehicle’s seat. You can buy the Lil Fan booster in 31 NCAA team colors hereĀ with free returns and free shipping. You can buy MLB booster seats for a range of teamshere. You can also buy diaper-toting backpacks for the NFL and NCAA and diaper-friendly messenger bags for the NFL and NCAA, as well as NCAA sling bags. Who knew car seat safety could be so sporty?

ā€”

If you find the information on car safety, recommended car seats, and car seat reviews on this car seat blog helpful, you can shop through this Amazon link for any purchases, car seat-related or not. Canadians can shop through this link for Canadian purchases.

Hauck Prosafe 35 Infant Car Seat Review: Safe, Affordable

I’ve been a fan of Hauck’s German car seats, strollers, portable cribs, and high chairs ever since I came across one of their artfully-designed strollers some years back. I learned about their first US-based car seat at the Las Vegas ABC Expo, and was happy to learn the Hauck Prosafe 35Ā (and its twin, theĀ iCoo iGuard 35)Ā were now available on Amazon with free shipping. I placed an order, wrote some 3 across guides while waiting, and settled down for a good review when it arrived. In short, it’s a good little infant seat that can be used to rear-face infants and toddlers who weigh between 4 and 35 pounds.

2015 Hauck Prosafe 35 – what’s the big deal?

hauck 1The Hauck Prosafe 35 is a straightforward and parent-friendly infant car seat. I like it because it’s sturdy, relatively affordable, and can be used with babies big and small. It’s not my favorite infant car seat on the market, the Kiddy Evolution Pro, as you can’t use it for nearly as long before your child outgrows it. However, the Prosafe 35 does well in its own right by allowing you to rear-face your baby as long as s/he weighs between 4 and 35 pounds, and having a tall enough shell to allow you to take advantage of much of that weight limit.

The Prosafe 35 and iGuard 35 feature a number of goodies including a seatbelt lock-off, a pair of recline angles depending on the weight of your child, high end LATCH lower anchor connectors, a good amount of EPP energy-absorbing foam for buffered side impact protection, a lightweight aluminum handle with an anti-rebound feature, and a reversible infant insert that can be used to either help cool your baby or keep him or her warm.

More broadly, the Prosafe 35 / iGuard 35 is an infant seat, which means you can only use it while rear-facing, but that you can use it from the day your child leaves the hospital. Remember, however, that you can use convertible seats when leaving the hospital if you choose to.

If you use an infant seat like the Prosafe 35 / iGuard 35, you’ll definitely still want to pick up a convertible seat in a year or two to enable you to continue to rear-face. There are a number of great choices which I’ve reviewed here. The main reason to choose an infant seat like the Prosafe 35 as a first car seat instead of a convertible seat is that it’s going to be a lot lighter and easier to install.

Buy the 2015 Hauck Prosafe 35 on Sale at Amazon here.

2015 Hauck Prosafe 35 Limits for Weight and Height

hauck 1Rear-facing: 4 to 35 pounds. Your child can be up to 32″ tall. The shell itself is 21″ tall, which is taller than the limits on many infant seats today, and the standard 1″ rule applies; the top of your child’s head can’t come within an inch of the top of the head support. An infant insert is included that comes in two parts: fabric and foam. You need to use the insert with the foam wedgeĀ when your baby weighs under 11 pounds, while you can choose to use the insert without the foam if your baby is between 11 and 22 pounds.

Even though the vast majority of states still permit forward-facing once your child has turned 1Ā (except for New Jersey!), as a reader of The Car Crash Detective, I hope you’ll consider rear-facing for longer (such as until 2, 3, or even 4 if you can), the way our Swedish brothers and sisters do. Remember that rear-facing is the safest position we know of for children of all ages.

Once your daughter or son has outgrown the Prosafe 35 by weight or height, she or he will need a convertible seat to continue rear-facing. Ā I’ve spent years reviewing the best convertible car seats on the market here.

Dimensions and Lifespan of the Hauck Prosafe 35

hauck 4The ProSafe 35 weighs 10 pounds without the base and 8 more pounds with the base attached. It’s not the lightest seat on the market by a long shot, but it’s not bad for short trips. The lowest harness position is 5.5″ without the infant insert, while the highest is 11.” The shell height tops out at 20″ when you factor in the 1″ rule.

The ProSafe 35 can be used for up to 7 years (commonly known as the car seat’s “lifespan”), and needs to be replaced once it’s been involved in a crash. Seven years after the date of manufacture, you will need to buy a new car seat (and here’s why). It also comes with a 2-year warranty, which is great, since most car seats come with a 1-year warranty.

The interior width of the ProSafe is 9″ at the base and 11″ at the shoulders; the exterior width is 14.5″ at the base and 19″ including the handles. The handle width makes it more of a challenging seat for 3 across car seat installations than an infant seat like the KeyFit 30 or B-Safe 35 Elite.

Using the Hauck Prosafe 35

hauck 3Installation with base: recline and seat belt lock off

The Prosafe 35’s claim to fame is the recline lever that doubles as a seat belt lock off. Having a good recline angle is essential when transporting an infant due to their extremely small airways, which is why pretty much every infant seat base allows you to adjust the recline to accommodate your vehicle’s seat angle.

Hauck aimed to make this process easier by allowing you change your base angle without moving your base from the seat. You set the base where you want it to go and open the red lock-off. From there, you push the lock-off to the vehicle seat back and raise the base so the recline foot can drop. To reduce your recline setting, you simply push the lever once more while you allow the base to drop to your desired angle.

Since you can use the lever to lock your seat belt at the same time, you can both tighten your belt and lock your recline and belt once you get a good recline angle. The seat belt lock off isn’t necessary in modern cars, but it’s a nice bit of insurance that your belt won’t go moving once it’s in place.

When using seat belts, keep in mind that the inflatable kind (such as those found in some models of the Ford Explorer, for example) may not be used with the seat. This goes for both based and baseless installations.

You can see your recline indicator on top of the Prosafe’s base, which makes it easy to use while installing the base. You can choose between a pair of recline positions. One is for babies who weigh less than 22 pounds, while the other is for babies who weigh more.

Installation with base: LATCH

The LATCH connectors are the push-in style and work smoothly. You can store your connectors in the base in a tiny compartment for each connector. The manual can also be stored in the base. You can buy an extra base (handy for installing the seat quickly in multiple vehicles) here.

LATCH borrowing in the center is allowed if the vehicle’s manufacturer allows you to do so and if there is less than 22″ between the two anchors. Most vehicles don’t allow LATCH borrowing, so keep that in mind before attempting to do so and make sure it’s specifically permitted in the manual.

Installation without base

hauck 2The baseless installation for the Prosafe 35 is also straightforward, thanks to the large and flat base of the infant seat, which makes the installation stable. You can use a pool noodle to firm up the installation if necessary, but you probably won’t need it. A good safety tip is to angle the handle toward the back of the vehicle’s seat to give you anti-rebound protection; the handle is made of aluminum and designed to offer such protection.

Child Fit

I tried the Prosafe 35 with a variety of training dolls and children and it did a great job with just about all of them. Because the harness height starts at 5,” infant inserts are available, and the crotch positions are adjustable, it’s a very flexible seat for infants of all sizes. The largest child I tried was 12 months old, 30.5″ tall, and 24 pounds; she still had a good amount of room in terms of height and shoulder width, which means this is an infant seat you’re likely going to be able to use up to a year and maybe a bit past it before switching to a convertible.

Regarding the infant insert, there are two parts to keep in mind: fabric and foam. You use the fabric insertĀ with foam when your baby weighs between 4 and 11 pounds, and you use the fabric insertĀ without the foam when your baby weighs between 11 and 22 pounds. There are two fabric choices available with the insert; one is grey and smooth while the other is fuzzy and white. The slick fabric is better in hotĀ weather while the fuzzy one is better in cold weather, but you can use either at any time.

The crotch strap is like the recline settings for the Prosafe 35 in that you can choose between two positions: one is for when babies weigh less than 22 pounds, while the other is for when they weigh more.

There are a pair of harness loops to choose from; unfortunately, you don’t get a no-rethread harness here, as you do in a seat like the Click Connect 40. The upper loops are designed to be used with babies at the 4-11 pound range, and the loops fit into the lowest harness slots available in the shell. The three higher slots are designed to be used with the loops for babies who weigh more than 8 pounds. The instructions are repeated on labels sewn into the harness loops, so don’t worry if you forget ahead of time.

Additional goodies

Additional things I like about the Prosafe 35 include its compatibility with a pair of strollers, the iCoo Acrobat and the Hauck Twister. According to Hauck, more strollers and adapters compatible with the Prosafe 35 will be released next year.

I’m a fan of the machine-washable cover included with the Prosafe 35. I also like how easy it is to install and remove the canopy and cover on the seat. I’m not a fan of the fact that you need to spot clean both the harness and the canopy, but the harness spot cleaning is pretty standard across most car seats due to the importance of not damaging the fabric with harsh detergents.

As is the case with most infant car seats, the Prosafe 35 can be used on airplanes per the FAA. However, it can only be used without the base; for some reason, the base isn’t FAA approved. This just means you’ll use a seat belt install with the seat.

Buy the 2015 Hauck Prosafe 35 on Sale at Amazon here.

Why Buy the Hauck Prosafe 35?

In the end, there are a lot of infant seats to choose from today in the United States, which can make the process of bringing your baby home in one a bit of a challenge. You can choose from models like the safe and popular Chicco KeyFit 30 to what I consider the best infant seat on the market today, the Kiddy Evolution Pro. The best reasons to base purchasing decisions on car seats, in my opinion, involve how well the seats do keeping children safe. For me, that starts with rear-facing.

Unless you have a child with very special needs, such as a highly premature infant who is in need of an infant bed, your infant should start out rear-facingĀ in either an infant seat or in a convertible seat in the rear-facing position. I prefer starting out with infant seats since they’re lighter and since you can install multiple bases to effortlessly move seats from one vehicle to the next.

Infant seats also make it much easier to transfer sleeping infants from the vehicle to the home, or vice versa. That said, no infant seat, not even the best available today in the United States, the Kiddy Evolution Pro, will get your child to age 4, which is where I believe we need to aim for when it comes to rear-facing, the way the Swedes do. To get to 4, you’re going to need to switch to a convertible seat somewhere along the way; I’ve reviewed plenty of these here.

However, even though it won’t get you to 4, the Prosafe 35 will almost certainly get you past 1, and will keep your child safe and cozy inside it all the while. More importantly, you’ll get a secure installation without much trouble, which is essential when you keep in mindĀ how many car seats are improperly installed each day. IĀ heartily recommend the Hauck Prosafe 35, and you can buy it here in black. You can buy an extra base here. You can buy the Prosafe 35 with the Twister Plus stroller here or with the iCoo Acrobat Plus stroller here.Ā Unfortunately, it’s not available in Canada, but the closest Canadian equivalent I’d recommend is the KeyFit 30, availableĀ here.

ā€”

If you find the information on car safety, recommended car seats, and car seat reviews on this car seat blog helpful, you can shop through this Amazon link for any purchases, car seat-related or not. Canadians can shop through this link for Canadian purchases.

The Best Rear-facing Convertible Car Seats for Leg Room

The Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 is one of the two best convertible car seats I've found for preserving front row leg room.
The Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 is excellent for preserving front row room.

I frequently get emailsĀ from parents either thanking me for the 3 across car seat guides I made for their vehicles or asking for suggestions for vehicles I haven’t yet tested with my fleet of car seats. For those parents, I came up with the list of narrow convertible car seats that will fit 3 across in just about any vehicle (including in a number of coupes and convertibles). However, another question I frequently get from parents involves which car seats will help them preserve front-to-back space in their cars. Believe it or not, this isn’t just an issue for parents driving subcompact or compact cars; many messages come from parents driving mid-sized or large SUVs or even minivans.

Why make a comparison of convertible car seats with the best front-to-back space?

Sometimes it’s because the vehicle inherently doesn’t have much front-to-back space to speak of, but many times, it’s because one parent or the other might be tall or have long legs. Other times one or both parents might simply want to be able to stretch their legs out and get comfortable during road trips. Sometimes it’s because of drivers or passenger who want to sit as far away from the steering wheel or dashboard as possible for fear of airbag deployments, car collisions, or due to pregnancies. Other times it’s due to having friends of different shapes and sizes.

Whatever the reason, since creating the 3 across guides, this has become one of the most frequent questions I receive or that draws people to the site in online searches. The goal is to find a high-quality, high weight- and height-limit convertible car seat that’ll keep your child safe, happy, and comfy rear-facing as long as possible, while at the same time allowing front-row occupants a safe and comfortable amount of room. Let’s get to it.

How did you measureĀ the convertibles that took up the least amount of passenger space?

measuring the graco size4me 65 - smallMy methodology was simple: I chose a vehicleĀ I’ve used for my 3 across guides and installed every rear-facing convertible seat I had access to in the passengerĀ outboard position. I measured the available space between the front of the vehicle seat in which the car seat was installed (at the head rest) and the most forward-reaching partĀ of the car seat. If the car seat had accommodations I could provide to reduce the amount of space it took up, such as the multiple recline positions in a Britax Advocate ClickTight or the angle adjuster option for a Diono Radian RXT or the removable anti-rebound bar for a Clek Fllo, I used it, as long as it didn’t create an unsafe recline angle.

I then ranked all of the car seats in the list below by the minimum measured distance I was able to achieve between the front of the vehicle seat and the most forward part of the car seat. The seats with the smallest measured distances are at the top of the list; these are the seats that are likely to use the least amount of space in your vehicle when you install them rear-facing the way I did. The seats with the largest measured distances are at the bottom of the list; these seats are likely to take up more front-to-back space in a given vehicle, leaving you with less space in the front row.

Will this list tell me if a car seatĀ will give me lots of spaceĀ in my car, minivan, SUV, or pickup truck?

Unfortunately, I can’t say if you’ll get as much space as I did in your vehicle; there are a lot of different factors that go into that, including the size of your vehicle, the angles of both your vehicle and car seats, whether your seats can move forward and back or not, and of course the amount of space your driver and front-seated passenger need. However, what this listĀ will tell you is how much space individual seats can take up when installed rear-facing. This, in turn, tells you whether one seat is likely to give you more or less room than another, and which seats, on average, are likely to give you the most or least space.

I’ve also included links to my reviews of the seats and their weight and seated height limits while rear-facing. The seated height limits are a measurement of the amount of available height in a seat from the bottom of the seat to the top, keeping in mind 1″ rules when applicable. In other words, they tell you how tall a seated child could be before outgrowing the seat; if two seats have the same weight limit, the seat with the higher seated height will last the child longer before needing to be forward-faced. All seats are tested in their most upright positions with head rests in fully extended positions unless otherwise noted.

It’s not a complete list, but I’ll continue to add to it as I get more seats. Each of these seats is one I’ve reviewed and laudedĀ on my recommended convertible car seat list. The equivalent Canadian recommended convertible list is here. The list below compares the most popular convertible car seats available in the US, sorted by the amount of front-to-back space they take up once installed in rear-facing configurations

Convertible Car Seat (Click on the car seat nameĀ for review) Front-to-back space usedĀ (in) Rear-facing weight limit (lbs) Rear-facing measured seated height of child (in)
Ā Maxi-Cosi Pria 85 31 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 25 inches
Ā Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 31Ā  inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Britax Advocate ClickTight 32 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 28 Ā inches
Ā Britax Boulevard ClickTight 32 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 28 Ā inches
Ā Britax Marathon ClickTight 32 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 26 Ā inches
Ā Britax AdvocateĀ G4.1 33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 24 Ā inches
Ā Britax Boulevard G4.1 33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 24 Ā inches
Ā Britax Marathon G4.1 33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 24 Ā inches
Ā Britax Pavilion G4 33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 24 Ā inches
Ā Britax Advocate G4 33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 24 Ā inches
Ā Chicco NextFit 33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 26 Ā inches
Ā Diono Radian RXT
(withĀ 
angle adjuster)
33 inches Ā 45 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Diono Radian R120
(withĀ 
angle adjuster)
33 inches Ā 45 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Diono Radian R100
(withĀ 
angle adjuster)
33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Diono Rainier
(withĀ 
angle adjuster)
33 inches Ā 50 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Diono Pacifica
(withĀ 
angle adjuster)
33 inches Ā 50 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Diono Olympia
(withĀ 
angle adjuster)
33 inches Ā 45Ā pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
Ā Graco Size4Me 65
(with flush head rest)
33Ā  inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 27 Ā inches
Ā Graco My Size 65
(with flush head rest)
33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 27 Ā inches
Ā GracoĀ Head Wise 70
(with flush head rest)
33 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 27 Ā inches
Ā Peg Perego Primo Viaggio ConvertibleĀ (w/ flush head rest) 33 inches Ā 45 pounds Ā 24 Ā inches
Ā Evenflo Triumph 34 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 23 Ā inches
Ā Evenflo Symphony 34 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 23Ā  Ā inches
Ā Graco 4Ever All-In-One 34 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 27 Ā inches
Ā Graco Milestone All-In-One 34 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 27 Ā inches
Ā Graco Contender
(with flush head rest)
34 inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 27 Ā inches
Ā Clek Fllo
(without anti-rebound bar)
35 Ā inches Ā 50 pounds Ā 26 Ā inches
Ā Clek Foonf 36 Ā inches Ā 50 pounds Ā 26 Ā inches
Ā Safety 1st Advance EX 65 Air+ 36 Ā inches Ā 50 pounds Ā 28 Ā inches
Ā Safety 1st Advance SE / LX 65 Air+ 36 Ā inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 28 Ā inches
Ā All Diono convertibles
(withoutĀ 
angle adjuster)
38 Ā inches Ā 40 pounds Ā 25 Ā inches
More Seats to Come!

It’s important to repeatĀ that you’re not necessarily going to get exactly the same results in your particular vehicle with a particular seat. However, this is a great starting point, and for many parents, it can make the difference between between a great amount of leg room and a very unpleasant driving or passenger experience, between forward-facing at 1 and forward-facing at 4, and ultimately, in the amount of safety we can provide our children while we travel. I’ve included below some additional notes and tips about several of the seats in the above list.

pria2 Maxi-Cosi Pria 85Ā ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
Maxi-Cosi Pria 70 – Review here, buy here.

The Pria 85 and 70 are the two convertibles that took up the least amount of space while rear-facing in this comparison. This makes these two seats the friendliest convertibles with 40-pound rear-facing limits for vehicles with limited front-to-back space.

When reclining, you can choose between the full recline of position #3 or the partial recline of position #2. The angle indicator is a line that’s supposed to be level to the ground. If you need to increase your recline angle, you can do so with either a tightly rolled towel or a pool noodle beneath the base.

advocate3Britax Advocate ClickTightĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
Britax Marathon ClickTightĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
Britax Boulevard ClickTightĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.

The 3 ClickTight triplets were the next-best convertibles for front-to-back space within the 40 pound RF weight limit, and also among the convertibles with the highest seated height limits at 28 inches. It’s important to note that the Marathon ClickTight seated height tops out at around 26 inches; if you’ve got a taller child, you might want to go with the Advocate CT or Boulevard CT instead.

With the ClickTight triplets, you can choose from 7 different recline positions in the base to get the rear-facing recline angle you need as suggested by the angle indicator. The more upright you can get the seat, the more space you’ll have. Keep in mind that newborns and young babies will naturally need more recline than toddlers or older children.

advocate4-1-1The Britax BoulevardĀ G4.1 ā€“ Review Here, Buy Here.
The Britax Marathon G4.1 ā€“ Review Here, Buy Here.

The G4.1 and G4 seats are also great choices for rear-facing without taking too much space from front-seat occupants. There are 3 recline positions available in total, but you can only use one of them when rear-facing. If you need to use a tightly rolled towel or a pool noodle beneath the base to find an appropriate recline angle, you can do so without worry. This is most likely to be the case if you have extremely sloped car seats and have a newborn or infant in the seat.

nex1Chicco NextFit Zip ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.

The NextFit has one of the highest seated heights I’ve yet measured (26 inches) for a 40-pound convertible seat currently on the market, which helps prolong the time you’ll be able to use it for rear-facing.

You can choose between 9 recline positions on the base to find an appropriate recline angle while rear-facing; the angle indicator will tell you what’s in a safe range and what’s not. The more upright your recline, the less space the seat will take up front-to-back. The ability to choose from so many different angles is part of what makes the NextFit such a good seat for smaller vehicles.

purplerainierDiono Radian RXTĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
Diono Radian R120Ā ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
Diono Radian R100Ā – Review here, buy here.
Diono RainierĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.

The Diono convertible family ranges from the R100 with a 40-pound RF limit to the Rainier and Pacifica with 50-pound RF limits. The RXT, R120, and Olympia are in between with 45-pound RF limits. All of the seats have the same basic design, and all of the seats are wonderful for small cars and small spaces when used with the angle adjuster. All of the seats also take up a largeĀ amount of space hen used without the angle adjuster. Remember that you can only use the angle adjuster if your child has full head control and can sit up without help.

s4m1TheĀ Graco Size4Me 65Ā ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
TheĀ Graco Fit4Me 65Ā ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
TheĀ GracoĀ ContenderĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.

The Graco clones are my favorite budget convertible car seats for extended rear-facing. They all rear-face until 40 pounds and include the second-highest seated child height limits in their class; the only 40-pound convertibles that will allow you to rear-face longer than the Graco seats here are the ClickTight convertibles.

That said, the Gracos are not all created equally. While they all share the feature of 3 recline positions with only 1 allowed when rear-facing, the Contender takes up more space when installed in the same seat than the other Graco clones. I’m not sure why, but it’s something to keep in mind, and another reason to buy the Size4Me or My Size over the Contender if you can afford to. You can increase your recline angle in all of the clones with either a tightly rolled towel or a pool noodle stuffed beneath the base.

pegpinkĀ Peg Perego Primo ViaggioĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.

The Primo Viaggio convertible is one of the best-performing seats on the list when it comes to the space it saves while rear-facing, especially since it doesn’t need an angle adjuster to provide the space it does while letting you rear-face until 45 pounds, unlike the Radian RXT, Radian R120, and Olympia.

The Primo Viaggio lets you use only one recline position when rear-facing. You can also choose between the first 7 head rest height settings when rear-facing; the top 3 are only allowed when forward-facing. As is the case with most seats on the list, you can increase your recline angle as needed through a tightly rolled towel or pool noodle beneath the base.

flloinkClek FoonfĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here, BuyĀ Here.
Clek FlloĀ ā€“ ReviewĀ Here,Ā Buy Here.

The Clek seats are among my favorite rear-facing convertibles, as they’re two of a handful of seats that allow rear-facing from birth until 50 pounds when used with the infant insert.

The Fllo allows you to use only one recline position when rear-facing. To make the most of it, you’ll want to remove the anti-rebound bar; that’ll give you about two more inches of space to play with in the front row. Although I like the anti-rebound bar, it’s an optional feature in the Fllo, and rear-facing will give you the biggest bang for your buck anyway. If you need more of a recline angle, you can use a tightly rolled towel beneath the base. Unlike most of the seats on this list, the Fllo doesn’t permit the use of a pool noodle.

The Foonf also lets you use recline position 3 when rear-facing. However, unlike with the Fllo, you can’t remove the anti-rebound bar when rear-facing. The Foonf as a result takes up about an inch more space than the Fllo when rear-facing. However, unlike with the Fllo, you can use either a tightly rolled towel or a pool noodle to increase your recline angle if you need to.

Conclusion – what’s the best seat for rear-facing space? It depends on your needs!

In conclusion, it can be tough figuring out what the best convertible seats will be for your son or daughter in your particular vehicle. The truth of the matter is that there isn’t a universally “best” seat. Whenever parents ask me for such a seat, I never have any in mind until I’ve thoroughly listened to or read their concerns, as each family’s situation will influence what the best solutions are for them. With that in mind, I’m hoping this will serve as yet another resource for parents and caretakers in search of high-quality convertibles to keep their little ones safe without placing front occupants into dangerous or uncomfortable situations.

If you’re still looking for more information to help you decide which seat is right for your little one, I’d recommend checking out the plethora of recommended car seat reviews and best practice articles I’ve written here. If you’d like to know about the narrowest car seats that will fit in just about any vehicle, you can read my recommendations here. And if you’d simply like to get an idea of some of the car seats that are likely to fit in your vehicle, you owe it to yourself to check out the gargantuan 3 across car seat guide I’ve written up (and continue to add to) here, spanning vehicles of all sizes, years, models, and price brackets.

These are good lists to have in mind when Amazon launches their seasonal car seat sales, such as those on Prime Day, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday; when you have the chance to score a deal, you want to make sure the seat you’re saving money on is a quality one.

If you find my information on best practices in car and car seat safety helpful, you can do your shopping through this Amazon link. Canadians can shop here for Canadian purchases. Have a question or want to discuss best practices? Join us in the forums!

Diono Radian R100 Review: Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
The Radian R100 remains one of the best options for extended rear-facing while maximizing 3 across installation options.

Diono is one of my favorite car seat manufacturers now, as they’re determined to make it possible to rear-face for longer in the United States. Reviewing best practices suggests that extended rear-facing is the least risky way of transporting children in passenger vehicles, so whatever makes this more feasible makes our children safer. I’ve reviewed their latest convertible models, theĀ Rainier, Pacifica, and Olympia, and have been thrilled with all of them (although the Pacifica and Olympia have since been discontinued).

2018 update: The Diono Radian R100 continues to be one of the absolute narrowest and best options for rear-facing in the United States and Canada. The only significant changes in the last few years have been in fabric options; the seat is fundamentally the same.

However, their older flagships, such as the Radian RXT, Radian R120, and Radian R100, are still excellent seats that can keep the average child rear-facing until s/he turns at least 4, per Swedish guidelines. The RXT, R120, and R100 also have several advantages over the three current Diono seats, including being cheaper and being the narrowest convertible car seats you can buy. Today we’ll take a look the Diono Radian R100 All-In-One Convertible Car Seat and why it’s worth considering as a cheaper alternative to the RXT and R120. You can buy the Radian R100 here.

Diono Radian R100 – What’s the big deal?

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
Several years after its release, the R100 continues to offer excellent rear-facing, forward-facing, and boostering options.

If you followed car seat developments in the last few years, especially around 2014, when there was only one option for 50-pound rear-facing (the Clek Foonf), you likely heard about the Diono Rainier,Ā Pacifica, andĀ Olympia. The first two seats were two of only a handful that allowed children to remain rear-facing until 50 pounds, while the third seat used to be one of the best on the market with a 45 pound RF limit. The Pacifica and OlympiaĀ  have since been discontinued, reducing the Diono convertible lineup to the Rainier and 3 Radian seats. However, the Diono Radian R100 is still well-worth considering for anyone interested in a 3-across friendly, extended rear-facing capable convertible car seat.

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
It’s available in four basic colors: black, grey, blue, and purple.

Technically, it’s an all-in-one convertible car seat, which means you can use it rear-facing for infants, toddlers, and preschoolers, and then turn it forward-facing to use during the elementary school years, and then even use it for a while as a booster seat. It’s a slightly older seat than a number of seats on the market right now, but it’s no less safe and should definitely be considered by every parent shopping for a new car seat.

Like the R120, it’s basically the same seat as the RXT except without the head support. The main differences between the R120 and the R100 are that there are slightly lower weight limits present in the R100. Oh, and it costs significantly less. You can skip down to the “Why Buy the Diono Radian R100” section if you just want a summary of why it’s worth it.

Diono Radian R100 Limits for Weight and Height

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
Most kids will be able to rear-face until at least 4, with many rear-facing to 5 in the R100.

Rear-facing: 5-40 pounds with a 44″ height limit. There is also a 1.5″ height limit relative to the top of the head rest; your child’s head can’t come within 1.5″ of the top of the seat, to put it more directly.

Forward-facing:Ā 20-65 pounds with a 57″ height limit. Diono stipulates a 1 year minimum for forward-facing and suggests waiting until s/he reaches at least 2. However, best practices suggests rear-facing for as long as possible. I recommend doing so at least until 4, which is daily practice in Sweden, where the fewest young children die per capita in car collisions. Here’s an article providing tips to keep your toddler rear-facing, if you need additional support making it possible.

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
Extended forward-facing, or extended harnessing, is a practical option with the R100, although you can switch directly to booster use as soon as 4 if your child is ready.

Booster mode:Ā 50-100 pounds with a 57″ height limit. The R100 is the same as the other Diono convertibles and all-in-ones in terms of the requirement that your child’s shoulders reach the 4th pair of harness slots before you use the R100 as a booster seat. Remember the 5-step test is your go-to-guide for determining when a child is ready to stop using a booster seat and start using a regular vehicle seat and seat belt. If your child doesn’t pass it, and most children won’t until they’re typically 10 to 12 years old, s/he’s not yet ready to sit safely without a booster.

Buy the Diono Radian R100 on Sale with Free Shipping at Amazon.

Dimensions of the Diono Radian R100

The R100Ā is 17″ wide at its widest point, making it one of the best convertible seats on the market right now for 3 across compatibility. It weighs approximately 26 pounds. The internal width is around 14″ at the shoulders and a bit more down at the thighs.

Using the Diono Radian R100

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
The R100 is built on a solid steel frame and is collapsible into a backpack shape for reasonably easy transportation.

When you unboxĀ the Radian R100, you’ll notice that it’s collapsed, which makes it easy to attach straps to it and carry it about like a backpack. This comes in handy if you’re traveling and need to use it in a portable situation like in a taxi (where car seats are still necessary) or on an airplane. Of course, it’s FAA approved and airplane compliant as a result. The LATCH straps are stored on the back of the seat, as well as a seat belt clip that you might need when installing the seat in an old car that doesn’t include a locking seat belt. The seat is a solid one, and it makes it easy to see the lineage of the later Dionos when examining it.

Harness adjustment

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
The harness straps must be threaded through the seat to adjust their height; there’s no quick adjust option here.

When installing it for the first time, keep in mind that you might need to adjust your harness straps to make sure they’re even. You have 5 shoulder harness positions to choose from, and there is a recline base that you need to use while rear-facing. Due to the wide range of harness slots and the good span of harness height, most children will find a position that fits them well while using the seat. The harness is unfortunately not a no-rethread design, but is still reasonably easy to adjust. To adjust it, you go behind the seat, pull the straps out of the splitting plate, and thread them into the harness slot you’d like to use.

When rear-facing your child, you’ll need to make sure the harness straps are either at your child’s shoulders or below them; when you’re forward-facing, the straps need to be above the shoulders. However, Diono does allow you to forward-face with your child’s shoulders above the highest shoulder harness slots as long as your child keeps within the weight limit for forward-facing and still has the tops of his or her ears below the highest part of the car seat. This is unique to Diono and shouldn’t be done with other seats.

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
You’ll be able to make 3 across setups work in the R100 with ease.

In many of my 3 across car seat guides where I reference Dionos, I’ll also reference the angle adjuster you can buy for them. It’s cheap, it’s compatible with all of the Diono all-in-one and convertible seats, and Ā it helps you reclaim a bunch of front-cabin space that would otherwise be compromised by the seat. It’s definitely a good idea to pick one up if you’re in a shorter vehicle (anything under about 190 inches) or if you’ve got taller drivers or passengers. The last thing you want to do is forward-face early because your child seat is a pain to use.

Buy the Diono Radian R100 on Sale with Free Shipping at Amazon.

Why Buy the Diono Radian R100?

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
…although I can’t guaranteed your kids will be this well behaved.

This is my favorite part of any review. To put it simply, I’d buy the Radian R100 because it offers many of the benefits of the more expensive Diono seats while costing a bit less. It allows you to rear-face your child for up to 40 pounds. That’s not nearly as good as it gets anymore, as there are a number of seats that will allow you to rear-face until 45 or even 50 pounds on the market, but it’s still good enough to get many kids to 4 while rear-facing. Remember that the longer you rear-face, the safer your child is. While parents tend to forward-face at 1 in the US, in Sweden, it’s not done until 4. As a result, it’s quite rare for a young Swedish child to die in a car crash. This here is why I’d buy the Radian R100.

How does the R100 compare to the R120, RXT, Rainier, Pacifica, and Olympia? (A short Diono convertible comparison)

Diono Radian R100 Review: It's Still Worth It! With RXT, R120 Comparisons
Here’s that steel frame I mentioned earlier underpinning the R100.

Besides that, I’m also a fan of the steel frame in the Radian R100, although I wish it had the aluminum reinforced head rest for additional head support as well as the EPS foam around the head for side impact protection that you get with seats like the Radian RXT and Rainier. You also get shallower sidewalls in the R100 compared to in seats like the RXT, Rainier, Pacifica, or Olympia, which results in slightly less side protection. If this matters to you, get the RXT, Rainier, Pacifica, or Olympia. If it doesn’t, get the R100 or R120. If you want to rear-face past 40 pounds and you want to do it in a Diono, go with the RXT, R120, Rainier, Pacifica, or Olympia. If you want to rear-face past 45 pounds in a Diono, your options are the Rainier or the Pacifica. If it doesn’t have to be a Diono, you can also choose between the Fllo and the Foonf.

In short, the Radian R100 is an incredibly narrow (17 inches!) seat that will make it one of a small number of seats possible to install 3 across in just about any vehicle. It’ll let you rear-face until 40 pounds and it costs less than any other Diono convertible on the market. It also has a 10 year lifespan as a booster and an 8 year lifespan when used rear- or forward-facing, which is about as good as it gets right now for a harnessed seat.

The Radian R100 is a great car seat and, in my opinion, still one of the best you can buy today in the US for children between zero and four. You can buy the Diono Radian R100 in Black Plum, Black Mist, Black Cobalt, and Essex prints here. Canadians can buy the Radian R100 here.

If you find my information on best practices in car and car seat safety helpful, you can do your shopping through this Amazon link. Canadians canĀ  shop here for Canadian purchases. Have a question or want to discuss best practices? Join us in the forums!